For sale

2351 Old Appalachian Trl

Fancy Gap, VA 24328

$670,000

  • 2beds
  • 1.5baths
  • 1,224sq ft
  • 17acres
  • 1946built

Listed by Keller Williams Realty Elite

About this home.

There are places you visit, and then there are places that quiet your heart & renew your spirit. Welcome to Mount Nebo—a private mountaintop sanctuary overlooking the breathtaking beauty of the Piedmont. Unforgettable long-range views of Pilot Mtn & beyond. In the morning, clouds & fog drift gently through the valleys below. As the sunlight reaches across the mountains, the landscape awakens with new colors, changing shadows, a beauty that never appears exactly the same twice. The front porch offers a peaceful place to breathe the mountain air, enjoy the stillness, & take in the magnificent surroundings. Abundant windows fill the home with natural light while keeping the remarkable view at the center of everyday life. The upper level features a spacious great room divided by a central staircase, creating distinct areas for relaxing, working, reading, dining, or entertaining. The kitchen offers its own unique character, with a granite-topped island while the home's European-style wet room adds another distinctive feature. Outdoor living is an essential part. The expansive deck offers room to entertain on a grand scale, with a swim spa, gas fireplace, & seating area overlooking the mountains. A 2nd deck features a wood-burning fireplace, observation area for grilling, gathering around the fire, or watching the colors change across the horizon. Hundreds of flowers representing dozens of varieties bloom throughout, creating an ever-changing display of seasons. A greenhouse, storage building, outdoor shower, circle drive, and generous parking. More than 17 acres provide an uncommon combination of privacy, peace, and freedom, without an HOA, restrictions, or the closeness of a crowded development. Whole-house generator, dual heat sources, tankless water heater. A place of refuge from the noise & demands of everyday life—a place to slow down, reconnect with nature, entertain the people who matter most, and experience the Blue Ridge Mtns from a new perspective.

Facts and features.

The home

Type
House (Single Family Residence)
Style
Cape Cod
Bathrooms
1 full, 1 half

Inside

Basement
Crawl Space
Fireplaces
None
Flooring
Carpet, Laminate, Wood
Appliances
Dryer, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Tankless Water Heater, Washer

Outside and lot

Garage
None
Exterior
Wood Siding, Dry Wall
Roof
Shingle
Outdoor features
Garden, Horses Allowed

Utilities

Heating
Heat Pump, Propane
Cooling
Heat Pump
Water source
Well
Sewer
Septic Tank

Community

HOA dues
None
County
Carroll County

The listing

Source
Southwest Virginia Association of REALTORS® MLS #111594

Price and status history.

81

days on market

DateEventPrice
Oct 17, 2026Listed for sale$670,000

Price per square foot

This home$547
Fancy Gap house median$163

Asking price per finished square foot, compared with the median of 8 houses sold in Fancy Gap in the last 12 months. 236% above the median.

Location.

2351 Old Appalachian Trl, Fancy Gap, VA 24328

Estimate a monthly payment.

Every number below is yours to change. The interest rate is an example, not a quote.

$3,590/mo

Principal and interest
$3,388
Property tax
$102
Home insurance
$100
HOA dues
None listed

Loan amount $536,000

Example rate only. Change it to the rate a lender offers you.

From the listing, 2026 taxes. Taxes can change after a sale.

Example. Use your quote.

An estimate for planning only. It is not a loan offer or a rate quote, and it leaves out mortgage insurance and closing costs. A lender can give you exact numbers.

Listing information

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Realty Elite.

Displayed by GRAVITY Real Estate Group.

Information last updated .

Listing information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Listings are courtesy of the listing brokerage shown with each property.

See it in person.

Request a tour.

Pick a day and a time. A GRAVITY agent will reach out to confirm.

Day
Time of day

A phone number or an email is enough.

We use your details only to reply about this home.

Ask a question.

Ask about the home, the neighborhood or the next steps. A GRAVITY agent will reply by email or phone.

A phone number or an email is enough.

We use your details only to reply about this home.